BFFs

Sanctuary

Four friends are holding each other at gunpoint down near Scooter’s Garage because one of them had stolen the group’s money. Question each of the four friends in order to maximize your reward—talking to each friend is its own simple bonus objective—and then accuse one of them of taking it.

Though it may sound as if more than one of the thugs is telling the truth, only one of them is being honest with you. In fact, you’re actually better off not listening to what the thugs have to say but going instead by what you see. And what you should notice is that Jim Kepler has a backpack with a large dollar sign on the back of it. Speak to all four friends, then turn and shoot Jim Kepler, as he’s the guilty party (O’Cantler was the only one being honest).