End #1: Geralt Of Rivia: Monster Mediator Of Kaer Morhen

If you’re attempting a more diplomatic end to this confrontation, you can reveal your past interactions with monsters, and prove you’ve been compassionate. Depending on which Contracts and other quests you have completed, you can present the following evidence to the Werewolf about your tendencies to spare the lives of non-humans:

• Salma Lilith: During Contract: Deadly Delights, if you let Salma Lilith go free (even though you knew she killed some guardsmen), you can mention this.
• Wham-a-Wham: If you completed Contract: Missing Miners and spared the troll that killed the miners, you can add this to your deeds.
• Trolls living near Kaer Morhen: During Main Quest: The Final Trial, if you stopped Lambert from harming the trolls, add this to the list.
• The Doppler in Novigrad: If you attempted Contract: An Elusive Thief, and forwent the bounty in return for letting the Doppler go, mention this.
• A deal with Fugas: During Secondary Quest: A Greedy God, if you let the sylvan live, your list of monster-saving grows ever-larger.
• Helping a Godling: During Main Quest: Novigrad Dreaming, if you helped Sarah stay in her Novigrad home, you make mention of this (as well as helping Johnny, which you had to do).

In order to win the majority of these four foes over, you must have saved at least two of the monsters listed previously. You can also change your mind mid-way through this explanation, and change to End #2. Assuming you keep your cool, only the werewolf climbs down from his perch. Slay him.

Afterward, the Godling rewards you for keeping your word, even after the “lost cause” in their troupe attacked you. Take the following as this quest concludes. There is no other reward (as “Uggo” was the Doppler).