Cohen’s Masterpiece is at the foot of the stairs, in the center of the Atrium. He calls it the Quadtych, as it consists of various statues holding four empty photo frames—one for each of his former disciples who he believes betrayed him. Kyle Fitzpatrick was the first of these betrayers. Approach Cohen’s Masterpiece and place the photo you took of the piano player’s corpse into the lower left frame. The Crossbow weapon rises from the stage floor as a token of Cohen’s gratitude.
Head back up the stairs towards Fleet Hall Theatre and loop around the Upper Atrium to the Cohen’s Collection area on the south side of the building. Cohen opens the bulkhead doors to Poseidon Plaza, but let it wait for now—there are three safes in the Cohen’s Collection gallery with your name on them!