Headsmans Cave

Headsman’s Cave is where the battle finally ends. Continue as before and Thunder eventually admits defeat, earning you the Thunder’s Helmet Trophy as a reward. Before leaving this dank chamber, Heroes wielding 15 Silver Keys or more can claim the Mana Augmentation from the Silver Key Chest nearby. When you’re ready, speak to the Demon Door outside.

Headsman’s Hill Demon Door

Well, how’s that for convenient? This Demon Door wants to see you defeat another Hero in battle—which you’ve just done. Head on through and you emerge back in Gibbet Woods. After a whole lot of effort (and, potentially, some light blackmail), you’re now ready to tie the knot with Lady Grey. Return to Bowerstone Manor to seal the deal.

The Greatest Prize of All

Agree to marry Lady Grey and all manner of gifts will be yours. Firstly, there’s a 15,000 Gold dowry for your troubles, and, next, you gain entry to Bowerstone Manor. Inside, you can swipe the Legendary Katana Hiryu from a 15-Key Silver Key Chest in the chamber to the north, plus a Silver Key from the bed nearby. Speaking of which, you’re now able to take a tumble in the sheets with your new bride. However, she’s a fussy sort—so it might take a few gifts and a quick tidy-up to improve your Attractiveness rating before your passionate advances pay off.

Now that you’ve found your “posh” bride, you might as well claim the Legendary Ronok the Axe from the Demon Door in the Grey House area. When you’re done, make your way to Lychfield Cemetery, north of Headsman’s Hill, where The Graveyard Path quest awaits.