| Achievement Name | Description | Xbox Points | PS Trophy | PS Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Going for Gold | Earn gold from a drill inside the Skills Trainer | 100 | Gold | 90 |
| Understanding | Earn at least one bronze medal in all drills inside of Skills Trainer | 140 | Silver | 30 |
| Threw Down the Gauntlet Again | Defeat the level 25 boss of the Skills Trainer Gauntlet | 50 | Gold | 90 |
| Run Degree | Earn at least a bronze medal in all six run concepts inside of Skills Trainer | 20 | Bronze | 15 |
| Early Bird | Get hit with a neutral zone infraction penalty (no SuperSim or Practice mode) | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Assisted | Record four assisted tackles in one game (no SuperSim or Practice mode) | 25 | Bronze | 15 |
| Lab Rat | Change one or more penalty sliders in the Settings menu | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Turn Down for Watt | Make a user-pick with J.J. Watt (no SuperSim or Practice mode) | 20 | Silver | 30 |
| Put Some Touch On It | Throw a TD using the touch pass (no SuperSim or Practice mode) | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Peanut Punch | Successfully use the strip ball mechanic (no SuperSim or Practice mode) | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Now Do It Again | Complete your first draft | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Good On Paper | Draft a team with an Overall rating greater than 82 in Draft Champions | 50 | Gold | 90 |
| Draft With Style | Build a team style (five players of a particular team style) | 35 | Silver | 30 |
| The Champion | Complete a draft without losing a single game | 20 | Bronze | 15 |
| Snickers You’re Not You When You’re Losing | Come back and win when trailing by 17+ points (no SuperSim or Co-op) | 30 | Silver | 30 |
| That Was Easy | Enter Draft Champions mode | 5 | Bronze | 15 |
| Grindin’ Solos | Win a MUT solo challenge | 20 | Bronze | 15 |
| Negotiator | Win a MUT auction | 15 | Bronze | 15 |
| Beyond A Hobby | Complete a MUT set | 20 | Bronze | 15 |
| Why Not Me In The Super Bowl? | Make it to a MUT seasons’ Super Bowl | 50 | Gold | 90 |
| This Is My Ultimate Team | Create a MUT team | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Stay Focused | Earn a first-round bye in Ultimate Team seasons | 25 | Bronze | 15 |
| Lay It All On The Line | Make the playoffs in Ultimate Team seasons | 20 | Bronze | 15 |
| Sammy Watkins Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 25 | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Ha-Ha Clinton-Dix Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 125 | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Teddy Bridgewater Legact Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 300 | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Le’Veon Bell Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 800 | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Matt Ryan Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 1,500 | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Ndamukong Suh Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 3,600 | 20 | Bronze | 15 |
| Marshawn Lynch Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 6,500 | 25 | Bronze | 15 |
| Darrelle Revos Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 9,500 | 30 | Bronze | 15 |
| Walter Payton Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 15,450 | 50 | Silver | 30 |
| Peyton Manning Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner, surpass a legacy score of 20,000 | 75 | Gold | 90 |
| Online Next? | Complete a single-player Draft Champions event | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Great Pick | Draft a player with an Overall rating at least 10 points higher than the base team | 10 | Bronze | 15 |
| Draftaholic | Complete five Draft Champions events | 25 | Silver | 30 |