How to Make the My Hero Cookie in Disney Dreamlight Valley - Prima Games

How to Make the My Hero Cookie in Disney Dreamlight Valley

Also known as a sugar cookie without sugar

by Madison Benson
Disney Dreamlight Valley My Hero Cookie

The My Hero Cookie in Disney Dreamlight Valley, known ingame as the “My Hero” Cookie, is an interesting pastry you’ll have to make if you want to complete your cooking log. Maybe it caught your eye because it’s the first to appear on the dessert list. Another reason could be because it reminds you of a certain anime with a similar name. Either way, if you want to cook every dish in the game, you’ll have to make this one eventually! If you’re interested in learning more, continue reading to discover how to make the My Hero Cookie in Disney Dreamlight Valley.

How to Make the My Hero Cookie in Disney Dreamlight Valley

The My Hero Cookie is a pastry with a pink ribbon and blue-green frosting. While this might sound slightly complicated, it isn’t nearly as difficult in the game. Instead, you just need three ingredients.

Below is the complete recipe to make the My Hero Cookie in Disney Dreamlight Valley:

  • Wheat x1 – Buy seeds from the Goofy Stall in Peaceful Meadow and grow them for one minute.
  • Butter x1 – Purchase from the Chez Remy pantry for 190 coins.
  • Any Sweets x1 – Includes sugarcane, cocoa beans and vanilla.

Related: How to Get Wheat Seeds in Disney Dreamlight Valley

When you encounter this recipe, you may wonder which sweet to use. After all, even though it says you can use any, this can sometimes backfire and cause you to make another dish.

In fact, this is an actual problem with this recipe! Below are the combinations for each sweet:

  • Wheat, Butter, Sugarcane = Biscuits
  • Wheat, Butter, Cocoa Beans = My Hero Cookie
  • Wheat, Butter, Vanilla = My Hero Cookie

The ingredient is listed as “Any” sweets because two different ones work for this recipe. However, if you use sugarcane, you’ll end up with Biscuits instead! With this in mind, avoid using sugarcane unless you also want to make biscuits.

Disney Dreamlight Valley is available to play on PC, Nintendo Switch, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, and PlayStation platforms through the official website. If you’re interested in learning more about the game, check out Where to Find Gooseberries and How to Unlock Peanuts. If you’d rather see the full list of every cooking recipe in the game, read our Disney Dreamlight Valley Cooking Guide.