Image Credit: Bethesda
Forgot password
Enter the email address you used when you joined and we'll send you instructions to reset your password.
If you used Apple or Google to create your account, this process will create a password for your existing account.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Reset password instructions sent. If you have an account with us, you will receive an email within a few minutes.
Something went wrong. Try again or contact support if the problem persists.
A mysterious woman in New World: Aeternum with her head thrown back, surrounded by an ominous red energy. The scene is dramatic, with the woman appearing to be unleashing dark power. The background is shadowy with a strong contrast of red glow around her.
Screenshot by Prima Games

New World: Aeternum Review | Fortune Favors The Bold

Carving out a space for consoles in the MMORPG genre.

Some games come with great expectations, and sometimes they fall short. Others suffer from rocky beginnings but manage to find their stride. New World: Aeternum is a bit of both. It launched with high hopes on PC, faced numerous challenges, and has now found a second wind with its console release. Let’s dive into the console version of this ambitious MMORPG.

Recommended Videos

A New Beginning

New World: Aeternum is Amazon Games Studios’ attempt to carve out a space in the MMORPG genre, now rephrased by AGS as an Action RPG to draw in the console crowd. Its initial PC release was marred by significant bugs and numerous unfinished elements that left players frustrated. The change in phrasing notably upset the PC community, as many felt that the game was, at its core, still a true MMORPG. Nevertheless, the console version brings in some much-needed polish, and both console and PC players alike are finding plenty to love about the game. Additionally, AGS have upped their game with a fresh update—to fix bugs and introduce new content—being rolled out just a week after the game’s official release.

A character in New World: Aeternum stands on a grassy hilltop with a musket on their back, gazing at a distant mountain with a bright magical aura at its peak. The scene is bright, depicting a serene, expansive view with various rock formations and a partly cloudy sky.
Screenshot by Prima Games

Immersive & Charming

New World: Aeternum shines in its world-building. The environment is not just massive but also beautifully rendered. It’s reminiscent of Red Dead Redemption 2 in that it easily draws players into its immersive scenery. Each moment in the game feels crafted to show off a stunning visual—whether it’s a lush forest, a seaside cliff, or a small village tucked into the hills. 

One of New World: Aeternum’s strongest aspects is the bottomless gathering and crafting system. Players can easily spend hours just exploring the world, hunting for resources, and progressing through different skills like smithing, cooking, and smelting. Crafting in New World: Aeternum is robust, rewarding, and truly makes the world feel alive—and it’s easy to get lost in it without even touching the PvP or PvE modes.

Two characters at a campsite in New World: Aeternum. On the left, Urda, a female character with short hair and tribal attire, is talking with arms crossed, while a male character wearing a blue tunic and leather armor listens attentively on the right. The background includes various camp supplies like barrels and hanging decorations.
Screenshot by Prima Games

The narrative is also a highlight, featuring well-written characters that help to enrich the story. The Scandinavian-inspired Fallen King Aelstrom and the pirate Grace O’Malley are just some fascinating side characters that make the lore engaging. Each character’s quirks add depth, making the world of Aeternum feel vibrant and filled with life.

A Work in Progress

Combat in New World: Aeternum, however, is a mixed bag. Initially, the system can feel stiff, especially if you’re more accustomed to fluid AAA action titles like God of War and Stellar Blade. Combat becomes more enjoyable once you unlock new abilities and experiment with different playstyles. The ability to re-spec without penalties gives you the freedom to find what works for you, which is a big plus.

Movement, particularly during combat, still feels like it could use some work. Issues like camera shudders and non-responsive blocks & dodges can take away from the experience. In some encounters, such as a battle against higher-level enemies, it’s easy to find yourself losing simply because your character fails to move properly. While these are minor issues, they do detract from the overall fluidity of the game. Addressing these concerns through patches would greatly enhance the gameplay. To sum it up, New World: Aeternum immerses players in a beautifully crafted environment where exploration and crafting shine, even as combat stumbles.

A character in New World: Aeternum, dressed in musketeer-style armor with a feathered hat, is firing a musket at an enemy. The character is positioned in a rocky narrow pathway, with surrounding stone walls and some torches in the background.
Screenshot by Prima Games

Lack of Enemy Variety

The enemy design in New World: Aeternum could also use more variety. The forces of corruption make up the bulk of your foes, with only the animals that roam the island of Aeternum offering that bit of much-desired flavor. The lack of diversity in enemies within the open world can make exploration feel repetitive at certain points. On the plus side, PvP remains an option for those who crave more dynamic encounters. While I haven’t yet delved into PvP myself, the community’s enthusiasm on platforms like Reddit suggests that it’s a highly enjoyable aspect of the game.

The Bigger Picture: MMOs on Console

Amazon Games Studios has taken on the ambitious task of bringing an MMORPG of this scale to consoles, something that has rarely been done successfully. The rephrasing of New World: Aeternum’s console release as an Action RPG might be a way to help it appeal to the respective platforms’ players, but make no mistake—this is still an MMO at heart. It leverages the power of next-gen consoles to deliver an experience that, while not without flaws, is impressive in scope and presentation. Time will tell if New World: Aeternum sets a precedent for future MMOs on consoles, but the potential is certainly there.

New World: Aeternum is an engaging MMORPG with a rich narrative and an immersive world that encourages exploration. Its crafting and gathering systems are compelling, and the expansive map is stunning. While the combat system has its limitations, particularly with movement issues, and the enemy variety is limited, the freedom to experiment with different weapons and abilities keeps things interesting. This game might not be perfect, but it’s definitely worth a try for anyone looking to lose themselves in a well-crafted virtual world for some time.

8
New World: Aeternum
A rebranded MMORPG that employs the genre's most beloved traits, effectively leverages the graphical capabilities of next-gen consoles and, in the end, does enough to make it worth your while.
Pros
  • Immersive environment
  • Deep crafting and gathering systems
  • Engaging characters and narrative
Cons
  • Stiff combat and movement issues
  • Limited enemy variety
A copy of this game was provided by the publisher for review. Reviewed on PlayStation 5.

Prima Games is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy